It felt a little weird for the second book I read in September to be a Christmas-centered novel. Sure, it's an Advanced Reader Copy, but still, it feels ridiculous. However, one thing we learn right off the bat is that Andy's wife, Laurie, wants to extend the Christmas season into February (I'm sure there's a touch of hyperbole there)—so I can totally see her not blinking at a Christmas book right after Labor Day.
There's another case that kicks the book off—Andy sues the Paterson Police Department on behalf of a canine officer whose handler is retiring and wants to bring the dog with him into early retirement due to hip problems. It's a pleasant way to kick off the book, and Rosenfelt makes it pay off for events later in the book and into the future, too.
But the main event is tied into Laurie's Christmas spirit. She goes to various local places (like a pet store) and takes the wish lists/letters to Santa left there and fulfills them. This year she gets a letter from a little boy who wants a coat for his mom and a sweater for his dachshund, but before you can say "Awww, how cute," he also asks for Santa to find his dad and bring him home. A job for Laurie, the P.I., not Santa.
Before Laurie can find him, however, the Paterson police do—he's arrested for a fourteen-year-old murder. Noah Traynor's sister had done one of those 23andMe/Ancestry-type things and the police tied her DNA to blood left underneath the fingernails of an unsolved murder (this is such a good idea, and I hope other writers use a similar idea just to prompt discussion about these things). Now we're talking a job that's not for Santa or Laurie, it's Andy's turn.
By this point, we all know what comes next: Sam hacks into things he should and finds out a lot; Marcus mumbles, intimidates some criminals and does something violent; Laurie cajoles and supports Andy; Hike predicts calamity; Andy watches some sports and thinks while walking Tara and Sebastian; (and works a little). The trial arrives and Andy annoys the judge and prosecutor, amuses the reader and finally gets somewhere with his investigation. Just because we all know it's coming, that doesn't mean it's any less entertaining—in fact, there's the fun in finding out how Rosenfelt will juggle the standard options; e.g. "what superhuman thing will Marcus do this time?", "will Sam get to go into the field?", "how many potential witnesses will Andy alienate before the trial? There's also a lot that happens this time that the reader isn't used to seeing during trial prep or the trial itself.
During the trial, something so shocking happened that Andy swore when he learned about it—which didn't scandalize me, I just don't remember him doing it that often. I was just as shocked as he was and almost followed suit. I know Rosenfelt has tricked me and caught me off guard before, but I don't remember anything like this one. At twenty books in, for him to leave me nigh-flabbergasted is an accomplishment. Early on, I'd come up with a theory for both the identity of the killer and the motive—and Rosenfelt had convinced me I was on the wrong track. But it turns out that the events that left me as gobsmacked as our favorite indolent defense lawyer paved the way for me to be proven right. I'm not bringing this up to talk about how clever I was but to say that Rosenfelt was so convincing that he talked me out of being right on both fronts. Few mystery writers succeed there, and that never fails to make me happy to read it.
The book also works as a launching point for the spin-off series expected next year, focusing on Laurie's new Detective Agency. I've been looking forward to it since I saw it announced, but now I'm a bit more interested having a bit more information. But more on that in a few months.
I went without sleep—2 days before seeing my sleep specialist, who saw the data, I should add—to stay up and finish this. It was totally worth the scathing look she gave me because I just had to know how it ended. After a book or two that made me wonder if Rosenfelt was running out of steam, the last few of these books have restored all my faith in him—Dachshund Through the Snow is one of the best in the series. A couple of authentic laughs, a lot of smiles, some warm fuzzies. a very clever mystery, and some good quality time with old friends—it's a genuinely good time.
Disclaimer: I received this eARC from St. Martin's Press via NetGalley in exchange for this post and my honest opinion—thanks to both for this early Christmas gift (so to speak), but the opinions expressed were not influenced by that, only by the fun read.