So, in a fast 265 pages Kevin Hearne gives us: Ragnarok; a lot of dead vampires; environmental crises; a friendly sloth; puppies; send-offs to many, many characters; shocking deaths; less-than-shocking deaths; surprise non-deaths; and more discussion of poots (elven and jaguar) than one'd expect in this kind of book. The amount that he accomplishes here is really staggering. Some of it, alas, could've been deeper -- explored more thoroughly -- if he hadn't set out to do so much or if he'd taken more time with some things (and less time with others). Still, this was a heckuva way to end the series.
This is not the book to start this series with, go back and read Hounded if you're curious (one of the best series kick-offs around), and I'm not going to get into the plot much. It's Ragnarok. We've all known it was coming and now it's here -- 'nuff said. Along those lines, however, Hearne also gets bonus points for including a "where we are in the series" introduction, summarizing the first 8 novels and the short stories/novellas that got us to this point. Again, this should be a requirement for long-running series.
There's no easy way to say it: there was just too much of Granuaile and Owen. Yes, it's the best use of Owen since his introduction, don't get me wrong. But it's the Iron Druid Chronicles -- fine, use the others if you want, but they shouldn't get equal time to the Iron Druid here in the last book. Especially given the number of things -- and scope of action -- that had to be accomplished in Atticus' story, it really should've had more room to breathe. That said -- for End-of-the-World Showdowns featuring deities from multiple pantheons? This rocked. He wrapped up the story he kicked off in Hammered and Two Ravens and One Crow in a fantastic fashion, full of death, blood and tension. At the same time, he maintained the very idiosyncratic characterizations he'd created for the various gods and goddesses.
Speaking of Two Ravens and One Crow, a small, but fun, point from that comes back in these pages in a way that no one could have expected and added just the right level of fun to the battle.
Hearne did a great job integrating the short stories from Besieged into this book -- I didn't expect to see so much from them carry over to this. It all worked well and set the stage for Hearne to get in to the action of Scourged right away and he took full advantage of that.
There were more than a few things that seemed like they needed better explanations -- doesn't the convenient dog sitter find the way that Atticus spoils his dogs more than a little strange? Given that they've known the clock was ticking on Ragnarok, why did Atticus wait until the last second to give Granuaile and Owen their assignments? I mean, it works out well for dramatic purposes, and allows certain plot points to be triggered, but that's not a good reason for the characters to work that way. At the very least, why weren't his former apprentice and his former teacher pestering Atticus to lay out his plans long before this? While I eventually saw what Atticus and Hearne were up to, in the moment, a lot of the plan just didn't make sense. When the world is falling apart, why set someone up for an extended training session (for one example)?
I'm not giving away anything about anyone dying -- or living -- but we know this is the finale, so we're seeing the end of stories for these characters. Some good, some shocking, some disappointing, some sad. In no particular order: Laksha got a nice send-off, I really didn't expect to see her here -- and I really appreciated what Hearne did with her. It's not honestly the ending I've had wanted for Atticus -- but it's the kind of ending that Hearne's been building to for a while now, so it's fitting. I can appreciate the way that Hearne accomplished his goals, even if I think Atticus deserved better. Owen's ending was everything you could've hoped for. Granuaile's story was fitting for her -- and a good reminder that I stopped liking her a few books ago (seriously, why couldn't she adopt an attitude similar to Owen or Flidias when it comes to their assignments during the battle?). I would've liked to have seen Perun one more time, but he got a good send off in Besieged.
Oberon was sidelined for most of the book -- I understand why: Atticus wanted to keep his buddy safe, and Hearne needed to keep things ominous, dramatic and threatening, which is hard to do with everyone's favorite Irish Wolfhound putting his two cents in (it's hard enough with Coyote around). Still, we got some good Oberonisms, and he elicited more than one smile from me -- and you could argue he saved the day ultimately. If I didn't know that Hearne was writing one more of Oberon's Meaty Mysteries, I'd be despondent over not seeing him again.
Scourged wasn't perfect, but it was very satisfying. If I have to say good-bye to these characters, this is a pretty good way to do it. There was enough excitement, drama, and happenings to fill a couple of books and Hearne got it all into one -- no mean feat -- and it was a great read. It's not easy letting go of most of these characters and this world (I mean, apart from re-reads), but I'm glad Hearne got out when he did and the way he wanted to. I'm looking forward to his future projects.