I still couldn’t see anything, which was unusual. Fae have excellent night vision. We’re like cats, able to see in the slightest trace of light. For it to be this dark, there had to be no light at all-that, or something had been done to my eyes. The thought caused a brief spike of panic, until I blinked several times and confirmed that I could still feel my eyes. No one had removed them or sealed my eyelids shut.
It says something about my life that this was a concern.
Surely, at some point, Toby will stop being lulled into a sense that everything is okay with the world -- she starts this book by enjoying life, and a night out with her friends. Which is one of the surest signs that things are going to go horribly awry for her. And they do, before she can finish unwinding after the night out, there's a knock on her door. Amandine, her mother, has stopped by for a visit.
Well, not really a visit. She wants to hire Toby to go find her older daughter, August. Toby's never met her sister and really doesn't want to get mixed up with anything involving August (who's been missing for over a century) or her mother. Amandine has never been one to take no for an answer, instead, she takes hostages.
So, Toby's off to find her sister August -- which makes preventing war (like she's been doing lately) look positively run-of-the-mill. I'm going to leave the plot summary at that. Because, like others, I don't know how to talk about this without spoiling things that shouldn't be. There are a couple of quotations (one from Toby, one from someone else) that illustrate what's going on beyond this missing person hunt:
All my chickens were coming home to roost, and while I didn't want them, I had earned them. I had earned them, every one.
“We are the sum of our actions . . . When desperation sets our course, those actions can blacken with remarkable speed.”
If that doesn't describe the last couple of Iron Druid Chronicles, Dresden Files, and pretty much every Alex Verus book, I don't know what does. The best of Urban Fantasy ultimately puts their protagonists in this situation -- Toby's been close to it before, but she's dancing closer to the line here, sacrificing (or at least being prepared to sacrifice) so much to find her sister -- and the number of things she won't sacrifice is pretty small.
There's not a whole lot of character growth and development here, there's no time. We do see many of our old friends and acquaintances being themselves -- maybe turned up to 11. One character, who will remain nameless, displays a degree of depth that we haven't seen before. Toby grows a bit through this experience, if only to find out what extremes she'll go to. She finds herself capable of changing her mind about someone --not easy for her to do (like most of us).
People are complicated. That’s the problem with people. lt would be so much easier if they could all be put into easy little boxes and left there, never changing, never challenging the things I decided about them.
This was a great read -- in more than just the story, or characters -- there are just some books where the whole is greater than the sum of its parts. This is one of them (though the sum of its parts was pretty good) -- everything just clicked. McGuire drew me in and kept me there between the voice, the fact that we have 10 books of history with these characters, and the drama (and little bit of comedy). There was one point, where Toby does something brave, reckless and potentially stupid (especially if it came back to bite her), where I found myself muttering, "Oh, oak and ash! No!" I figure any book that has you under its spell enough that you end up borrowing oaths and curses from the protagonist is a pretty engrossing read. She didn't listen to me, and she sure should have.
From the fun as all get out opening scene, to the ominous final sentence that should fill every Toby fan with dread (although it promises some great books), McGuire was firing on all cylinders here. Yeah, plenty came home to roost in The Brightest Fell, and it meant that those closest to Toby suffered, but she found a way to be Toby throughout -- she didn't surrender who she was, and she got things done the best she could. All the while bringing the reader along through her highs and lows with her. Can't ask for more than that. (well..I guess you could, but why?)